
Should you keep your money in Qaumi Bachat or a bank? Both are safe, but they differ in profit rate, tax, how easily you can withdraw, and who can invest. This comparison uses current rates so you can decide with real numbers.
National Savings vs Bank Profit Rates (November 2026)
| Option | Typical rate | Profit paid | Rs10 lakh per month (before tax) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Behbood / Pensioners’ Benefit | 12.96% | Monthly | Rs10,800 |
| Regular Income Certificate | 12.12% | Monthly | Rs10,100 |
| Sarwa Islamic Savings | 11.84% | Monthly | Rs9,867 |
| Bank saving account (conventional) | 10.5% minimum up to Rs1 crore (SBP rule) | Monthly | Rs8,750 |
| Bank 1-year term deposit | About 10.5%–12% | Monthly or at maturity | Rs8,750–Rs10,000 |
Bank rates vary by bank, balance slab and product. See bank profit rates and fixed deposit rates.
Safety: Government Guarantee vs Bank Deposit Protection
National Savings is a direct obligation of the Government of Pakistan, the safest rupee investment available. Bank deposits are covered by the Deposit Protection Corporation up to a limit per depositor per bank; large banks are very stable, but amounts above the limit carry bank risk.
Tax Comparison
Tax is where National Savings pulls further ahead. In 2026-27, most National Savings profit is taxed at 15% for filers and 30% for non-filers, while bank profit is taxed at 20% for filers and 40% for non-filers. Behbood and Pensioners’ Benefit have no tax deducted at source, putting them far ahead of any bank product for eligible people.
Flexibility and Withdrawal
- Banks: saving accounts allow withdrawal any time from an ATM or app. Term deposits can be broken early, usually with reduced profit.
- National Savings: certificates can be encashed early, but profit may be reduced and you need a centre visit or the CDNS digital portal.
Which Is Better for You?
| Your situation | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Widow or 60+ needing monthly income | Behbood (National Savings) |
| Retired government employee | Pensioners’ Benefit (National Savings) |
| Salaried, wants monthly income for 5 years | Regular Income Certificate, or a high-rate bank term deposit |
| Emergency fund you may need any day | Bank saving account |
| Wants an Islamic option | Sarwa Islamic or an Islamic bank account |
Example: Rs20 Lakh for One Year (Filer)
In RIC at 12.12%, Rs20 lakh earns Rs242,400 a year before tax, or Rs206,040 after 15% tax. A bank saving account at 10.5% earns Rs210,000 before tax, or Rs168,000 after 20% bank tax. National Savings pays about Rs38,000 more after tax. Check your own numbers with the National Savings calculator and the bank profit calculator, or read National Savings monthly income schemes.
When Banks Can Beat National Savings
When the policy rate rises, banks sometimes reprice term deposits faster than CDNS revises its rates. With the SBP policy rate at 12% since 26 October 2026, compare a few banks’ term deposit offers before locking money in. See profit on 1 crore in banks.
Not sure which option fits you?
We explain your options for free. Reach us on WhatsApp or at info@theinvestpakistan.com via the contact page. Your details stay private.
FAQs
Is National Savings better than a bank?
For monthly income and safety, National Savings usually pays more. Banks are better for money you may need to withdraw quickly.
Is bank profit taxed differently from National Savings?
Yes. Bank profit is taxed at 20% (filer) and 40% (non-filer); most National Savings profit at 15% and 30%. Behbood and Pensioners’ Benefit have no tax at source.
Which is safer, bank or National Savings?
National Savings is backed directly by the Government of Pakistan. Bank deposits are protected up to the Deposit Protection Corporation limit.
FAQs (Roman Urdu)
Bank behtar hai ya Qaumi Bachat?
Mahana income aur hifazat ke liye Qaumi Bachat aam tor par zyada munafa deti hai. Jo paisa kabhi bhi nikalna ho, wo bank mein rakhein.
20 lakh par bank aur Qaumi Bachat mein kitna farq hai?
RIC mein filer ko saal ka takreeban Rs206,000 aur 10.5% bank account mein (20% tax ke baad) Rs168,000 milta hai, yani takreeban Rs38,000 ka farq.